Ingredient guide

Is Carmine (E120) Halal? Cochineal and Scholarly Views

What carmine is, where it is used, why the schools of thought differ on insects, and plant-based colours to choose instead.

HalalVerify editorial team Updated 4 min read
Quick answer

Carmine (E120), also called cochineal, is a red colour made from crushed cochineal insects. Whether it's halal depends on how your school of thought treats insects. Many Maliki scholars allow it, and some scholars elsewhere accept it because so little is used or because they consider it transformed. Many Hanafi, Shafi'i and Hanbali scholars don't allow eating insects other than locusts, so they avoid it. Certifiers also differ. Carmine is always declared on the label, so it's easy to spot and easy to avoid if you choose to.

What carmine is

Cochineal is a small scale insect that lives on prickly pear cacti, farmed mainly in Peru and the Canary Islands. The female insects contain carminic acid, which they use to deter predators. The insects are dried and crushed, the colour is extracted with water, and it's usually combined with aluminium or calcium to make a stable pigment called carmine.

The result is a bright, heat-stable red that doesn't fade easily, which is why food manufacturers like it. It has been used as a dye for centuries.

Names to look for

  • E120
  • Carmine, carmines or carminic acid
  • Cochineal or cochineal extract
  • Natural Red 4, and CI 75470 in cosmetics

Where you'll find it

Carmine gives pink and red colours to:

  • strawberry and raspberry yoghurts, milkshakes and ice cream;
  • sweets, icing, glacé cherries and cake decorations;
  • some soft drinks, cordials and red alcoholic drinks;
  • some processed meats and seafood products such as surimi;
  • lipsticks, blushers and eye shadows.

Many manufacturers have switched to plant colours, but carmine is still common, especially in dairy and confectionery.

Why scholars differ

The question isn't about slaughter or intoxication but about whether insects may be eaten.

  • Insects are generally not eaten. Many scholars of the Hanafi, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools hold that insects other than locusts aren't permissible to eat, and apply this to carmine.
  • Some insects are permitted. Many Maliki scholars allow eating insects that aren't harmful, which would include cochineal.
  • The tiny amount and the change. Some scholars accept carmine because only a very small amount of pigment is used and it has been processed into a different substance, an argument similar to transformation (istihalah).
  • Purity versus eating. Many scholars consider insects without flowing blood to be pure (tahir) even when they aren't eaten. That's why carmine in lipstick or cosmetics is often treated more leniently than carmine in food.

Halal certifiers reflect these differences: some accept carmine in certified products and others don't. HalalVerify doesn't issue rulings. If carmine matters to you, ask the scholar you follow, or choose products coloured with plant alternatives.

Plant-based alternatives

If you'd rather avoid carmine, these colours give similar shades and raise no question about their source:

ColourE-numberSource
Beetroot red (betanin)E162Beetroot
AnthocyaninsE163Red cabbage, grapes, berries
Paprika extractE160cRed peppers
LycopeneE160dTomatoes
Allura red, Ponceau 4RE129, E124Synthetic

Products labelled vegan won't contain carmine. "Colouring foods" such as concentrated beetroot, carrot or radish juice are also plant-based.

How to check a product for carmine

  1. Read the colours. Look for E120, carmine or cochineal among the ingredients. It always has to be listed when used as a colour.
  2. Check the flavour versions. In a range of yoghurts or sweets, the strawberry or cherry versions are the most likely to contain it.
  3. Look for a vegan label or plant colours as a quick sign that carmine isn't used.
  4. Check halal-certified products if it matters to you. Because certifiers differ, a certified product might still contain carmine. If you avoid it, read the label even on certified products.

Frequently asked questions

Is carmine haram?

Scholars differ, so there isn't a single answer. It's widely accepted by many Maliki scholars and avoided by many others. Follow the view of the scholar or certifier you trust.

Is lipstick with carmine allowed?

Many scholars who don't allow eating insects still consider them pure, so they permit carmine in cosmetics. Others prefer to avoid it. Many brands now offer carmine-free lipsticks.

Does carmine cause allergies?

Rarely, but it can cause allergic reactions in some people. That's another reason some people choose plant-based colours.

How does HalalVerify mark carmine?

On every product page, carmine is listed with its status and the reason for it, so you can see what the status rests on and decide according to the view you follow. If a product you buy uses a plant colour instead, let us know so we can update the record.

Sources and further reading

Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 on food additives (E120 cochineal, carminic acid, carmines). Related guides: What are E-numbers?, What does mashbooh mean?, How halal certification works.

Keep reading

Type and Hit Enter to Search